-----CAKE PREORDERS ARE BOOKED UNTIL MARCH 9th BUT WE HAVE CAKES IN OUR CASES FOR WALK INS-----
soft serve ice cream nj best soft serve blue sheep bake shop
Soft Serve Ice Cream
$2.95
/products/soft-serve-ice-cream
4486768754735
Soft Serve Ice Cream
soft-serve-ice-cream
strawberry ice cream nj ice cream
Sold Out
Strawberry Ice Cream
$2.95
/products/strawberry-ice-cream-nj-ice-cream-shop
4486717014063
Strawberry Ice Cream
strawberry-ice-cream-nj-ice-cream-shop
sparkling unicorn ice cream nj ice cream shop
Sparkling Unicorn
$2.95
/products/sparkling-unicorn-nj-ice-cream-shop
4486731137071
Sparkling Unicorn
sparkling-unicorn-nj-ice-cream-shop
mad monkey ice cream banana peanut butter ice cream blue sheep bake shop
Sold Out
Mad Monkey Ice Cream
$2.95
/products/mad-monkey-ice-cream-blue-sheep-bake-shop-nj-ice-cream-shop
4486742442031
Mad Monkey Ice Cream
mad-monkey-ice-cream-blue-sheep-bake-shop-nj-ice-cream-shop
Sold Out
Rocky Road Ice Cream
$2.95
/products/rocky-road-ice-cream
4526025703471
Rocky Road Ice Cream
rocky-road-ice-cream
Sold Out
Pub Crawl Ice Cream
$2.95
/products/pub-crawl-ice-cream-1
4526007517231
Pub Crawl Ice Cream
pub-crawl-ice-cream-1
Lemon Bar Ice Cream
$2.95
/products/lemon-bar-ice-cream
4489282191407
Lemon Bar Ice Cream
lemon-bar-ice-cream
mint cookie fudge ice cream blue sheep bake shop ice cream somerville nj
Mint Cookie Fudge Ice Cream
$2.95
/products/mint-cookie-fudge-nj-ice-cream-shop
4486736740399
Mint Cookie Fudge Ice Cream
mint-cookie-fudge-nj-ice-cream-shop
Cookie Dough Ice Cream
$2.95
/products/cookie-dough-ice-cream
4498024923183
Cookie Dough Ice Cream
cookie-dough-ice-cream
oreo ice cream
Oreo Ice Cream
$2.95
/products/oreo-ice-cream
4486867550255
Oreo Ice Cream
oreo-ice-cream
coffee ice cream with cookies blue sheep bake shop nj ice cream
Sold Out
Mississippi Mud Pie Ice Cream
$2.95
/products/mississippi-mud-pie-ice-cream-blue-sheep-bake-shop-ice-cream-nj
4486753222703
Mississippi Mud Pie Ice Cream
mississippi-mud-pie-ice-cream-blue-sheep-bake-shop-ice-cream-nj
Peanut Butter Pie
$2.95
/products/pub-crawl-ice-cream
4486867091503
Peanut Butter Pie
pub-crawl-ice-cream
Ice Cream Pints
$6.45
/products/ice-cream-pints
4485826117679
Ice Cream Pints
ice-cream-pints
Thick & Creamy Milkshakes
From $6.45
/products/thick-cream-milkshakes
4479991513135
Thick & Creamy Milkshakes
thick-cream-milkshakes
Ice Cream Cups & Sundaes
$2.95
/products/ice-cream-cups-to-go-curbside-pick-up-somerville-nj
4484082565167
Ice Cream Cups & Sundaes
ice-cream-cups-to-go-curbside-pick-up-somerville-nj
Ice Cream Nachos
$5.65
/products/ice-cream-nachos
4485556371503
Ice Cream Nachos
ice-cream-nachos
Giant Chocolate Chip Cookie Party - 1 Day Notice
$29.95 Regular price $35.00
/products/giant-chocolate-chip-cookie-party-family-dessert-night
4477357883439
Giant Chocolate Chip Cookie Party - 1 Day Notice
giant-chocolate-chip-cookie-party-family-dessert-night
oreo ice cream sandwiches nj ice cream shop
Sold Out
6 Oreo Ice Cream Sandwiches
$18.00
/products/6-oreo-ice-cream-sandwiches
4479250694191
6 Oreo Ice Cream Sandwiches
6-oreo-ice-cream-sandwiches
NEW!!! Ice Cream Flights
$14.95
/products/ice-cream-flights
4718224375855
NEW!!! Ice Cream Flights
ice-cream-flights
×

Call for Price

I agree to my email being stored and used to receive the newsletter.