-----TO GO PREORDERS ARE BOOKED UNTIL JUNE 7TH. CUSTOM CAKES ARE BOOKED UNTIL JUNE 3, 2022. WE HAVE SIGNATURE & ICE CREAM CAKES IN OUR CASES FOR WALK-INS, SPECIALTY CAKES REQUIRE 4-6 WEEKS LEAD ---
Search
Loading...
Cart
soft serve ice cream nj best soft serve blue sheep bake shop
Vanilla Soft Serve
From $5.25
strawberry ice cream nj ice cream
Strawberry Ice Cream
$2.95
Sold Out
Rocky Road Ice Cream
$2.95
mint cookie fudge ice cream blue sheep bake shop ice cream somerville nj
Mint Cookie Fudge Ice Cream
$2.95
Cookie Dough Ice Cream
$2.95
oreo ice cream
Oreo Ice Cream
$2.95
Sold Out
Peanut Butter Pie
$2.95
Ice Cream Pints
$10.50
Thick & Creamy Milkshakes
From $7.25
Ice Cream Cups & Sundaes
$2.95
Sold Out
Ice Cream Nachos
$5.65
Giant Chocolate Chip Cookie Party - 5 Days Notice
$29.95 $35.00
oreo ice cream sandwiches nj ice cream shop
Sold Out
6 Oreo Ice Cream Sandwiches
$18.00
Ice Cream Flights
$8.95
×

Request Price

I agree to my email being stored and used to receive the newsletter.