Try our NEW Ice Cream Banana Split Lasagna

About Us

Now open for CURBSIDE pick up Tuesday through Saturday, 11-3 until the COVID-19 crisis has ended.
We've made a number of significant changes to our business model for the interim and are now a virtual bakery. You can place orders online & pickup within 15 minutes, call us when you arrive & park on Main Street at the north end of Division Street, 908.383.1824.  In order to protect ourselves, our families, and our clients we are not open to the public.

On a daily basis we will have:

  • Cupcakes, french macarons, bake at home cookies, dessert bars, brownies, & ice cream available for online ordering & curbside pick up
  • To go cake orders need 1-2 days notice, order online, subject to availability
  • Custom cake orders need about 1 week notice, subject to availability

 9 Division Street | Somerville | NJ 908.393.1824 | Email us here | 

Specialty Cakes | Specialty Cupcakes | Macarons | Macaron Favors | Gourmet Cupcakes | Decorated Sugar Cookies | Cake Pops | Dessert Tables | Ice Cream | Cookies | Brownies

Under normal business conditions:

Blue Sheep Bake Shop is a custom cake studio, gourmet cupcake bakery, and ice cream shop. We feature cupcakes, macarons, small to go cakes, and a full ice cream menu in store daily including: 12 flavors of cupcakes daily in both classic size and miniature size, 12 flavors of hard ice cream along with vanilla, chocolate and twist soft-serve ice cream, milkshakes, over the top milkshakes, ice cream sundaes, and custom ice cream sandwiches.

We also specialize in custom cakes and ice cream cakes including wedding cakes, shower cakes, and birthday cakes. We ask for 2 to 4 weeks notice for our specialty cakes & special orders although sometimes we can accommodate an order within that window. We recommend scheduling an appointment for a cake consultation and or tasting. 

Event and Corporate catering also available including delivery and set up services.