Custom Specialty Cake Flavors | Blue Sheep Bake Shop


At the Blue Sheep we believe cakes should taste as good as they look - and that's why we bake everything immediately before the event with top of the line ingredients and never freeze our cakes. Our cakes are fresh, moist, and rich in flavor.  

Below is a list of the cakes and fillings we provide. You can also take flavor inspiration from our cupcake menu. If you don't see what you're looking for -  just ask! 

Custom Cake Options Custom Cake Filling Options
Cake Choices
  • Almond
  • Banana
  • Birthday
  • Carrot*
  • Champagne*
  • Chocolate
  • Chocolate Chip
  • Cookies and Cream
  • Honey Cinnamon
  • Marble
  • Pink Velvet
  • Pina Colada*
  • Red Velvet
  • Strawberry
  • Yellow Vanilla
  • White Vanilla



    European Butter Cream fillings:

    • Vanilla Buttercream
    • Chocolate Buttercream
    • Oreos & Cream Buttercream
    • Espresso Buttercream
    • Mocha
    • Chocolate Ganache
    • Peanut Butter Buttercream
    • Almond Buttercream
    • Raspberry Buttercream
    • Strawberry Buttercream
    • Banana Buttercream
    • Mint Buttercream
    • Lemon Buttercream



            Premium Fillings $1 extra per serving

            • Cream Cheese**
            • Nutella Buttercream**
            • Cannoli Cream**
            • Chocolate or Vanilla Mousse**
            • Mango Mousse
            • Chocolate Ganache**
            • Fruit Preserve Swirl**
            * indicates premium cakes available at an extra cost ** indicates premium fillings available and and extra cost