-----TO GO PREORDERS ARE BOOKED UNTIL JUNE 7TH. CUSTOM CAKES ARE BOOKED UNTIL JUNE 3, 2022. WE HAVE SIGNATURE & ICE CREAM CAKES IN OUR CASES FOR WALK-INS, SPECIALTY CAKES REQUIRE 4-6 WEEKS LEAD ---
Search
Loading...
Cart
'Lil Cub Custom Birthday Cake
$0.00
Some Bunny Loves You Custom Birthday Cake
$0.00
Cyrus' Ghost Busters Cake
$0.00
Jack's Peter Rabbit Cake
$0.00
Mauve Floral Buttercream Cupcakes
$72.00
Teddy Bears & Balloons Custom 1st Birthday Cake
$0.00
Vintage Mickey Cake
$0.00
Belle Cupcakes
$60.00
Tea Party Bridal Shower Floral Cupcakes (Custom)
$72.00
filigree cross baptism cupcakes
Filigree Cross Custom Cupcakes
$72.00
Rosebud Buttercream Cupcakes (12)
$72.00
polar bear 1st birthday cake nj best cakes
Sold Out
Polar Bear 1st Birthday Cake
$0.00
Number 21 Carved Cake - Covered in Sprinkles! NJ Custom Cakes by Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Sold Out
21 Carved Number Cake with Sprikles
$0.00
Tiered Buttercream Art Party Birthday Cake - by Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Edie's Art Party Painting Cake NJ birthday cake
$0.00
Sally from A Nightmare Before Christmas Cake
Sold Out
A Nightmare Before Christmas Cake - Featuring Sally!
$0.00
Diary of a Wimpy Kid Birthday Cake, Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Sold Out
Diary of a Wimpy Kid Book Cake
$0.00
Tiffany Buttercream Baby Shower Cake NJ
Nela's Buttercream Tiffany Cake
$0.00
Miles' Barnyard 4th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Miles' Barnyard 4th Birthday Cake NJ
$0.00
Minecraft Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Minecraft Birthday Cake
$0.00
Handpainted Calvin and Hobbes Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Calvin and Hobbes Handpainted Birthday Cake
$0.00
1st Birthday Barnyard Farm Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Kaden's Barnyard 1st Birthday Cake NJ Birthday Cakes
$0.00
charlie brown snoopy woodstock birthday cake nj custom cakes
Charlie Brown and Snoopy Birthday Cake
$0.00
nursery rhyme custom 1st birthday cake nj
Nursery Rhyme 1st Birthday Cake
$0.00
Oh the places you'll go cake
Oh, The Places You'll Go Birthday Cake
$0.00
miles' uno first birthday cake nj
Miles' Uno Themed First Birthday Cake
$0.00
where the wild things are birthday cake nj
Where the Wild Things Are Birthday Cake NJ II
$0.00
custom cowgirl fondant birthday cake nj
Gingham Cowgirl Birthday Cake
$0.00
cow birthday cake nj
Avery's Cow Birthday Cake
$0.00
mickey mouse cake best cakes in nj
James' Mickey Mouse Cake
$0.00
twinkle twinkle little star buttercream baby shower cake nj best cakes
Buttercream Twinkle Twinkle Little Star Baby Shower Cake
$0.00
finding nemo dory cake nj
Finding Dory Cake
$0.00
Red Angry Birds Cake
$0.00
monster 1st birthday cake
Green and Orange Monster Cake NJ
$0.00
vintage carnival bar mitzvah cake nj
Vintage Carnival Bar Mitzvah Cake NJ
$0.00
Orange and Blue Monster Cake NJ
$0.00
pink and lavender baby shower cake nj
Clothesline Baby Shower Cake II
$0.00
chefs hat cake nj
Chef's Hat Birthday Cake NJ
$0.00
Mike Wazowski Cake
$0.00
plants vs zombies cake nj
Plants Vs. Zombies Ugly Sweater Cake
$0.00
circus carnival cake nj
Circus 1st Birthday Cake II
$0.00
Barnyard 1st Birthday Cake
$0.00
crayola crayon birthday cake NJ
Crayon Birthday Cake NJ
$0.00
circus carnival cake nj
Circus Birthday Cake II
$0.00
buttercream baby shower cake with clothesline
Clothesline Baby Shower Cake
$0.00
Classic Winnie Baby Shower Cake NJ
$0.00
amazing birthday cakes nj safari cake
Safari - Jungle 1st Birthday Cake
$0.00
where the wild things are 1st birthday cake nj
Where the Wild Things Are 1st Birthday Cake NJ
$0.00
twinkle twinkle little star cake nj
Twinkle Twinkle Little Star Baby Shower Cake
$0.00
×

Request Price

I agree to my email being stored and used to receive the newsletter.