Custom Specialty Cakes and Cupcakes NJ - Blue Sheep Bake Shop - Cupcakes, Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake, Shower Cakes
Gourmet Cupcakes
Available for in-store pickup!
French Macarons
Daily Flavors & Custom Order Favors
Cakes
Buttercream & Fondant Specialty Cakes

View All Cakes

For more information or to get a quote get in touch with us by email or phone at 908.393.1824. To view cakes by category click the + sign next to the word  'CAKE CATEGORIES' on the grey menu above.
Filter +
Jadas's Pink Ruffle Buttercream Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Jada's Ruffle Cake
-
$0.00
Jadas's Pink Ruffle Buttercream Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Jada's Ruffle Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Diary of a Wimpy Kid Birthday Cake, Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Diary of a Wimpy Kid Book Cake
-
$0.00
Diary of a Wimpy Kid Birthday Cake, Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Diary of a Wimpy Kid Book Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Deep Space Sweet 16 Cake
Deep Space Sweet 16 Cake
-
$0.00
Deep Space Sweet 16 Cake

Deep Space Sweet 16 Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Black Amethyst Geode Cake
Black Amethyst Geode Cake - NJ Custom Cakes, Blue Sheep
-
$0.00
Black Amethyst Geode Cake

Black Amethyst Geode Cake - NJ Custom Cakes, Blue Sheep

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
black and gold ruffle cake
Black and Gold Ruffle Cake
-
$0.00
black and gold ruffle cake

Black and Gold Ruffle Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Shimmer and Shine Birthday Cake - NJ Custom Cakes
Shimmer and Shine Slumber Party Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Shimmer and Shine Birthday Cake - NJ Custom Cakes

Shimmer and Shine Slumber Party Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Starry Nights Sweet 16 Cake - NJ Custom Cakes, Blue Sheep
Starry Nights Sweet 16 Cake
-
$0.00
Starry Nights Sweet 16 Cake - NJ Custom Cakes, Blue Sheep

Starry Nights Sweet 16 Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Blue Ombre Rosette Sweet 16 Cake
Blue Ombre Rosette Sweet 16 Cake
-
$0.00
Blue Ombre Rosette Sweet 16 Cake

Blue Ombre Rosette Sweet 16 Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Pink, Mint, and Gold Mermaid Cupcakes
Pink & Mint Mermaid Cupcakes
-
$0.00
Pink, Mint, and Gold Mermaid Cupcakes

Pink & Mint Mermaid Cupcakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Dabbing Unicorn Ice Cream Cake - NJ Ice Cream Cakes
Dabbing Unicorn Ice Cream Cake - NJ Ice Cream Cakes
-
$0.00
Dabbing Unicorn Ice Cream Cake - NJ Ice Cream Cakes

Dabbing Unicorn Ice Cream Cake - NJ Ice Cream Cakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Naked Ice Cream Cake - NJ Ice Cream Cakes
Pink and Gold Naked Ice Cream Cake
-
$0.00
Naked Ice Cream Cake - NJ Ice Cream Cakes

Pink and Gold Naked Ice Cream Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Fortnite Battle Royal Cake - NJ Custom Cakes, Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Fortnite Battle Royale Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Fortnite Battle Royal Cake - NJ Custom Cakes, Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Fortnite Battle Royale Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Fall Inspired Coronet Buttercream Cake NJ
Fall Inspired Coronet Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Fall Inspired Coronet Buttercream Cake NJ

Fall Inspired Coronet Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Afro Puff Birthday Cake
Afro Puff Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Afro Puff Birthday Cake

Afro Puff Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Sculpted Shih Tzu Birthday Cake NJ
Shih Tzu Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Sculpted Shih Tzu Birthday Cake NJ

Shih Tzu Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Zombie Cake
Sculpted Zombie Cake
-
$0.00
Zombie Cake

Sculpted Zombie Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Red, White, and Gold Fondant Wedding Cake NJ
Red, White, and Gold Wedding Cake nj
-
$0.00
Red, White, and Gold Fondant Wedding Cake NJ

Red, White, and Gold Wedding Cake nj

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Buttercream cake with black fondant stripes and fresh flowers.
Black and White Striped Buttercream Bridal Shower Cake NJ
-
$0.00
Buttercream cake with black fondant stripes and fresh flowers.

Black and White Striped Buttercream Bridal Shower Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Hand Painted Winnie the Pooh Cookies
Hand Painted Winnie the Pooh Cookies
-
$0.00
Hand Painted Winnie the Pooh Cookies

Hand Painted Winnie the Pooh Cookies

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Hand painted Winnie the Pooh Baby Shower Cake NJ
Hand Painted Winnie the Pooh Baby Shower Cake NJ
-
$0.00
Hand painted Winnie the Pooh Baby Shower Cake NJ

Hand Painted Winnie the Pooh Baby Shower Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Jewelry Inspired Birthday Cake NJ
Jewelry Inspired Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Jewelry Inspired Birthday Cake NJ

Jewelry Inspired Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Tiffany Buttercream Baby Shower Cake NJ
Nela's Butterccream Tiffany Cake
-
$0.00
Tiffany Buttercream Baby Shower Cake NJ

Nela's Butterccream Tiffany Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Fortnite Cake - Rainbow Smash PIck Axe Birthday Cake nj
Fortnite Cake - Rainbow Smash PIck Axe Birthday Cake nj
-
$0.00
Fortnite Cake - Rainbow Smash PIck Axe Birthday Cake nj

Fortnite Cake - Rainbow Smash PIck Axe Birthday Cake nj

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
nintendo console birthday cake nj
Nintendo Console Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
nintendo console birthday cake nj

Nintendo Console Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
lego birthday cake nj
Luca's Lego BirthdayCake
-
$0.00
lego birthday cake nj

Luca's Lego BirthdayCake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
shark birthday cake nj
Shark Inspired Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
shark birthday cake nj

Shark Inspired Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
white and gold henna wedding cake nj
White and Gold Henna Inspired Wedding Cake NJ
-
$0.00
white and gold henna wedding cake nj

White and Gold Henna Inspired Wedding Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
dr who birthday cake nj
Dr. Who Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
dr who birthday cake nj

Dr. Who Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
hobbit juice craft beer can cake nj custom cakes
Craft Beer Can Cake
-
$0.00
hobbit juice craft beer can cake nj custom cakes

Craft Beer Can Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Fondant Birch Wedding Cake NJ
Fondant Birch Wedding Cake with Peony Sugar Flowers
-
$0.00
Fondant Birch Wedding Cake NJ

Fondant Birch Wedding Cake with Peony Sugar Flowers

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Pink and White Buttercream Drip Cake with Goodies
Pink and White Buttercream Drip Cake with Goodies
-
$0.00
Pink and White Buttercream Drip Cake with Goodies

Pink and White Buttercream Drip Cake with Goodies

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Moana Inspired Buttercream Birthday Cake
Moana Inspired Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Moana Inspired Buttercream Birthday Cake

Moana Inspired Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Buttercream Birch Wedding Cake with Fall Leaves
Buttercream Birch Wedding Cake with Fall Leaves
-
$0.00
Buttercream Birch Wedding Cake with Fall Leaves

Buttercream Birch Wedding Cake with Fall Leaves

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Hatchet Throwing Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Hatchet Throwing Cake Tree Stump Cake
-
$0.00
Hatchet Throwing Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Hatchet Throwing Cake Tree Stump Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Rainbow Unicorn Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Rainbow Unicorn Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Rainbow Unicorn Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Rainbow Unicorn Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Blush and Burgundy Buttercream Floral Coronet Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Blush and Burgundy Coronet Buttercream Cake With Buttercream Flowers
-
$0.00
Blush and Burgundy Buttercream Floral Coronet Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Blush and Burgundy Coronet Buttercream Cake With Buttercream Flowers

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Standing Sculpted LOL Doll Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
LOL Doll Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Standing Sculpted LOL Doll Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

LOL Doll Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Lumberjack Baby Shower Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Lumberjack Baby Shower Cake
-
$0.00
Lumberjack Baby Shower Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Lumberjack Baby Shower Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Burgundy and Gold Buttercream Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Burgundy Buttercream Floral Cake
-
$0.00
Burgundy and Gold Buttercream Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Burgundy Buttercream Floral Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Pokemon Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Pokemon Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Pokemon Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Pokemon Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Woodland Character Fall Inspired Baby Shower Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Woodland Character Baby Shower Fall Inspired Cake
-
$0.00
Woodland Character Fall Inspired Baby Shower Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Woodland Character Baby Shower Fall Inspired Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Buttercream Pumpkin Smash Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Hunter's Buttercream Pumpkin Smash Cake
-
$0.00
Buttercream Pumpkin Smash Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Hunter's Buttercream Pumpkin Smash Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Tiered Golf Themed 30th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
David's 30th Birthday Golf Themed Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Tiered Golf Themed 30th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

David's 30th Birthday Golf Themed Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Pumpkin Patch First Birthday Cake Custom Cakes NJ
Hunter's Pumpkin Patch 1st Birthday Cake NJ custom cakes
-
$0.00
Pumpkin Patch First Birthday Cake Custom Cakes NJ

Hunter's Pumpkin Patch 1st Birthday Cake NJ custom cakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Miles' Barnyard 4th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Miles' Barnyard 4th Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
Miles' Barnyard 4th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Miles' Barnyard 4th Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Buttercream 1st Birthday Cake with Fresh Flowers and Wafer Paper Butterflies - NJ custom cakes
Buttercream Floral 1st Birthday Cake with Butterflies
-
$0.00
Buttercream 1st Birthday Cake with Fresh Flowers and Wafer Paper Butterflies - NJ custom cakes

Buttercream Floral 1st Birthday Cake with Butterflies

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Minecraft Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Minecraft Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Minecraft Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Minecraft Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Handpainted Calvin and Hobbes Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Calvin and Hobbes Handpainted Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Handpainted Calvin and Hobbes Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Calvin and Hobbes Handpainted Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Black and White Striped Buttercream Cake with Pink Flowers - Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Black and White Striped Buttercream Cake With Pink Florals NJ
-
$0.00
Black and White Striped Buttercream Cake with Pink Flowers - Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Black and White Striped Buttercream Cake With Pink Florals NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Pink Watercolor Inspired Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Pink Watercolor Cake with Buttercream Flowers
-
$0.00
Pink Watercolor Inspired Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Pink Watercolor Cake with Buttercream Flowers

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →