Custom Specialty Cakes and Cupcakes NJ - Blue Sheep Bake Shop - Cupcakes, Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake, Shower Cakes
Gourmet Cupcakes
Available for in-store pickup!
French Macarons
Daily Flavors & Custom Order Favors
Cakes
Buttercream & Fondant Specialty Cakes

View All Cakes

For more information or to get a quote get in touch with us by email or phone at 908.393.1824. To view cakes by category click the + sign next to the word  'CAKE CATEGORIES' on the grey menu above.
Filter +
Hatchet Throwing Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Hatchet Throwing Cake Tree Stump Cake
-
$0.00
Hatchet Throwing Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Hatchet Throwing Cake Tree Stump Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Rainbow Unicorn Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Rainbow Unicorn Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Rainbow Unicorn Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Rainbow Unicorn Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Blush and Burgundy Buttercream Floral Coronet Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Blush and Burgundy Coronet Buttercream Cake With Buttercream Flowers
-
$0.00
Blush and Burgundy Buttercream Floral Coronet Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Blush and Burgundy Coronet Buttercream Cake With Buttercream Flowers

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Standing Sculpted LOL Doll Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
LOL Doll Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Standing Sculpted LOL Doll Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

LOL Doll Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Lumberjack Baby Shower Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Lumberjack Baby Shower Cake
-
$0.00
Lumberjack Baby Shower Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Lumberjack Baby Shower Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Burgundy and Gold Buttercream Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Burgundy Buttercream Floral Cake
-
$0.00
Burgundy and Gold Buttercream Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Burgundy Buttercream Floral Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Pokemon Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Pokemon Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Pokemon Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Pokemon Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Woodland Character Fall Inspired Baby Shower Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Woodland Character Baby Shower Fall Inspired Cake
-
$0.00
Woodland Character Fall Inspired Baby Shower Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Woodland Character Baby Shower Fall Inspired Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Buttercream Pumpkin Smash Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Hunter's Buttercream Pumpkin Smash Cake
-
$0.00
Buttercream Pumpkin Smash Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Hunter's Buttercream Pumpkin Smash Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Tiered Golf Themed 30th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
David's 30th Birthday Golf Themed Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Tiered Golf Themed 30th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

David's 30th Birthday Golf Themed Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Pumpkin Patch First Birthday Cake Custom Cakes NJ
Hunter's Pumpkin Patch 1st Birthday Cake NJ custom cakes
-
$0.00
Pumpkin Patch First Birthday Cake Custom Cakes NJ

Hunter's Pumpkin Patch 1st Birthday Cake NJ custom cakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Miles' Barnyard 4th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Miles' Barnyard 4th Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
Miles' Barnyard 4th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Miles' Barnyard 4th Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Buttercream 1st Birthday Cake with Fresh Flowers and Wafer Paper Butterflies - NJ custom cakes
Buttercream Floral 1st Birthday Cake with Butterflies
-
$0.00
Buttercream 1st Birthday Cake with Fresh Flowers and Wafer Paper Butterflies - NJ custom cakes

Buttercream Floral 1st Birthday Cake with Butterflies

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Minecraft Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Minecraft Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Minecraft Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Minecraft Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Handpainted Calvin and Hobbes Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Calvin and Hobbes Handpainted Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Handpainted Calvin and Hobbes Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Calvin and Hobbes Handpainted Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Black and White Striped Buttercream Cake with Pink Flowers - Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Black and White Striped Buttercream Cake With Pink Florals NJ
-
$0.00
Black and White Striped Buttercream Cake with Pink Flowers - Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Black and White Striped Buttercream Cake With Pink Florals NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Pink Watercolor Inspired Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Pink Watercolor Cake with Buttercream Flowers
-
$0.00
Pink Watercolor Inspired Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Pink Watercolor Cake with Buttercream Flowers

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Bas Relief Inspired Buttercream Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Uriella's Bas Relief Inspired Burgundy Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Bas Relief Inspired Buttercream Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Uriella's Bas Relief Inspired Burgundy Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Kate Spade Inspired 30th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Kate Spade Inspired 30th Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Kate Spade Inspired 30th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Kate Spade Inspired 30th Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Gold Drip & Succulents Wedding Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Gold Drip Wedding Cake with Succulents NJ
-
$0.00
Gold Drip & Succulents Wedding Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Gold Drip Wedding Cake with Succulents NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
1st Birthday Barnyard Farm Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Kaden's Barnyard 1st Birthday Cake NJ Birthday Cakes
-
$0.00
1st Birthday Barnyard Farm Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Kaden's Barnyard 1st Birthday Cake NJ Birthday Cakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Harry Potter Themed Wedding Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Harry Potter Wedding Cake
-
$0.00
Harry Potter Themed Wedding Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Harry Potter Wedding Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Tea Party Bridal Shower Cake NJ
Tea Party Bridal Shower Cake with Fondant Tea Cup
-
$0.00
Tea Party Bridal Shower Cake NJ

Tea Party Bridal Shower Cake with Fondant Tea Cup

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Buttercream & lace christening cake NJ
Landon's Buttercream & Lace Christening Cake NJ
-
$0.00
Buttercream & lace christening cake NJ

Landon's Buttercream & Lace Christening Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Ariel Little Mermaid Under the Sea Theme NJ Custom Birthday Cakes
Mermaid Under the Sea Custom Birthday Cake nj
-
$0.00
Ariel Little Mermaid Under the Sea Theme NJ Custom Birthday Cakes

Mermaid Under the Sea Custom Birthday Cake nj

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Mermaid Birthday Cupcakes NJ
Mermaid Birthday Cupcakes
-
$0.00
Mermaid Birthday Cupcakes NJ

Mermaid Birthday Cupcakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Harry Potter Birthday Cupcakes NJ
Harry Potter Birthday Cupcakes
-
$0.00
Harry Potter Birthday Cupcakes NJ

Harry Potter Birthday Cupcakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Under the sea themed buttercream birthday cakes in NJ.
Under the Sea Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
Under the sea themed buttercream birthday cakes in NJ.

Under the Sea Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Black and white fondant sweet 16 cake with glitter and ruffles NJ
Glittery Black and White Sweet 16 Cake with Ruffles and Quilting
-
$0.00
Black and white fondant sweet 16 cake with glitter and ruffles NJ

Glittery Black and White Sweet 16 Cake with Ruffles and Quilting

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Gender Reveal Pink and Blue Drip Cake with Fondant Baby Sneakers NJ
Pink and Blue Baby Shower Cake with Baby Sneakers NJ
-
$0.00
Gender Reveal Pink and Blue Drip Cake with Fondant Baby Sneakers NJ

Pink and Blue Baby Shower Cake with Baby Sneakers NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Belle Beauty and the Beast Cake - Custom Cakes by Blue Sheep
Beauty & The Beast Belle Cake NJ
-
$0.00
Belle Beauty and the Beast Cake - Custom Cakes by Blue Sheep

Beauty & The Beast Belle Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
charlie brown snoopy woodstock birthday cake nj custom cakes
Charlie Brown and Snoopy Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
charlie brown snoopy woodstock birthday cake nj custom cakes

Charlie Brown and Snoopy Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
floral wreath christening cake nj cakes
Blush and Gold Christening Cake With Sugar Floral Wreath
-
$0.00
floral wreath christening cake nj cakes

Blush and Gold Christening Cake With Sugar Floral Wreath

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
naked baby shower cake with pink roses nj cakes
Naked Baby Shower Cake with Fresh Pink Roses
-
$0.00
naked baby shower cake with pink roses nj cakes

Naked Baby Shower Cake with Fresh Pink Roses

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
number 2 #2 minnie mouse inspired birthday cake nj cakes
Number 2 Minnie Mouse Inspired Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
number 2 #2 minnie mouse inspired birthday cake nj cakes

Number 2 Minnie Mouse Inspired Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
unicorn and lol doll birthday cake nj
Unicorn and LOL Doll Inspired Birthday Cake NJ best cakes
-
$0.00
unicorn and lol doll birthday cake nj

Unicorn and LOL Doll Inspired Birthday Cake NJ best cakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
30th Birthday Watercolor Cake with Sugar Flowers
30th Birthday Watercolor Cake with Sugar Flowers
-
$0.00
30th Birthday Watercolor Cake with Sugar Flowers

30th Birthday Watercolor Cake with Sugar Flowers

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Naked Wedding Cake with Blue Hydrangea
Naked Wedding Cake with Blue Hydrangea
-
$0.00
Naked Wedding Cake with Blue Hydrangea

Naked Wedding Cake with Blue Hydrangea

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Blush Lace Wedding Cake
Blush Lace Wedding Cake
-
$0.00
Blush Lace Wedding Cake

Blush Lace Wedding Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
pink and blue gender reveal macaron drip baby shower cake nj custom cakes
Tiered Pink & Blue Gender Reveal Macaron Chocolate Drip Cake NJ cakes
-
$0.00
pink and blue gender reveal macaron drip baby shower cake nj custom cakes
Images / 1 / 2

Tiered Pink & Blue Gender Reveal Macaron Chocolate Drip Cake NJ cakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
buttercream birthday cake with sprinkles and buttercream swirls
Blue Swirls and Sprinkles Cake
-
$0.00
buttercream birthday cake with sprinkles and buttercream swirls

Blue Swirls and Sprinkles Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
confetti to go cake nj bakery cakes
Confetti To Go Cake
-
$0.00
confetti to go cake nj bakery cakes

Confetti To Go Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Flamingo To Go Birthday Cake
Flamingo To Go Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Flamingo To Go Birthday Cake

Flamingo To Go Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Black, White, and Pink Striped To Go Birthday Cake NJ
Black, White, and Pink Striped To Go Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
Black, White, and Pink Striped To Go Birthday Cake NJ

Black, White, and Pink Striped To Go Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Mermaid Watercolor Drip Cake with Macarons
Mermaid Watercolor Drip Cake with Macarons
-
$0.00
Mermaid Watercolor Drip Cake with Macarons

Mermaid Watercolor Drip Cake with Macarons

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Lavender and Pink Watercolor Drip Cake with Macarons
Lavender and Pink Watercolor Drip Cake with Macarons
-
$0.00
Lavender and Pink Watercolor Drip Cake with Macarons

Lavender and Pink Watercolor Drip Cake with Macarons

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Pink and Teal Donut Drip Cake
Pink and Teal Donut Drip Cake NJ Cakes
-
$0.00
Pink and Teal Donut Drip Cake

Pink and Teal Donut Drip Cake NJ Cakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Purple, Pink, and Pearls to go cake!
Purple, Pink, and Pearls to go cake!
-
$0.00
Purple, Pink, and Pearls to go cake!

Purple, Pink, and Pearls to go cake!

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
memorial day 4th of july labor day buttercream cake nj
Memorial Day Chocolate Drip Celebration Cake
-
$0.00
memorial day 4th of july labor day buttercream cake nj

Memorial Day Chocolate Drip Celebration Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
buttercream birthday cake with confetti nj cake shop
Confetti Triangle Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
buttercream birthday cake with confetti nj cake shop

Confetti Triangle Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →