Birthday Cakes | Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Gourmet Cupcakes
Available for in-store pickup!
Classic Buttercream Cakes
Beautiful Buttercream Cake Designs
ICE CREAM CAKES
AVAILABLE FOR IN STORE PICKUP AND SPECIAL ORDER

Browse our collection of custom specialty birthday cakes for inspiration or contact us to design something special - just for you! This collection features specialty cakes for teens and adults - birthday cakes, 40th birthday cakes, 30th birthday cakes, sweet 16 cakes, quinceanera cakes, and more. Browse our custom cake flavors here, or classic cake flavors here.   

Birthday Cakes

Filter +
batman vs joker 50th birthday cake handpainted nj
Hand-painted Batman Vs Joker 50th Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
batman vs joker 50th birthday cake handpainted nj

Hand-painted Batman Vs Joker 50th Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
blue monster smash cake nj
Hudson's 1st Birthday Monster Smash Cake NJ
-
$0.00
blue monster smash cake nj

Hudson's 1st Birthday Monster Smash Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Pink Ombre Rosette and Lace 21st Birthday Cake NJ
Pink Ombre Rosette and Lace 21st Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
Pink Ombre Rosette and Lace 21st Birthday Cake NJ

Pink Ombre Rosette and Lace 21st Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
beauty and the beast cake nj
Beauty and the Beast Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
beauty and the beast cake nj

Beauty and the Beast Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
50 and fabulous birthday cake navy and gold nj
Navy and Gold 50 and Fabulous Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
50 and fabulous birthday cake navy and gold nj

Navy and Gold 50 and Fabulous Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
dr pepper soda can cake nj
Soda Can Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
dr pepper soda can cake nj

Soda Can Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
sephora make up birthday cake nj
Sharon's Sephora Makeup Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
sephora make up birthday cake nj

Sharon's Sephora Makeup Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Zoey's Buttercream Butterfly 1st Birthday Cake
Zoey's Buttercream Butterfly 1st Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Zoey's Buttercream Butterfly 1st Birthday Cake

Zoey's Buttercream Butterfly 1st Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
black and white striped birthday cake nj
Black and White Striped Couture Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
black and white striped birthday cake nj

Black and White Striped Couture Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
50th Birthday Black and White Chanel Inspired Cake
50th Birthday Black and White Chanel Inspired Cake
-
$0.00
50th Birthday Black and White Chanel Inspired Cake

50th Birthday Black and White Chanel Inspired Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
classic alice in wonderland birthday cake nj
Classic Alice In Wonderland Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
classic alice in wonderland birthday cake nj

Classic Alice In Wonderland Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
gold pink chocolate drip cake nj
Liana & Giada's Pink, Chocolate, and Gold Drip Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
gold pink chocolate drip cake nj

Liana & Giada's Pink, Chocolate, and Gold Drip Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
buttercream 1st birthday cake nj
Lil Pumpkin 1st Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
buttercream 1st birthday cake nj

Lil Pumpkin 1st Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
chefs hat cake nj
Chef's Hat Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
chefs hat cake nj

Chef's Hat Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
nerf birthday cake nj
Nerf Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
nerf birthday cake nj

Nerf Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
vintage pink and gold birthday cake nj
Pink and Gold Vintage 60th Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
vintage pink and gold birthday cake nj

Pink and Gold Vintage 60th Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
pink rosette ombre cake with gold bow nj
Pink Ombre Rosette Birthday Cake with Gold Bow
-
$0.00
pink rosette ombre cake with gold bow nj

Pink Ombre Rosette Birthday Cake with Gold Bow

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
home depot birthday cake
Home Depot Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
home depot birthday cake

Home Depot Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
naked cake with flowers and berries nj
Naked 21st Birthday Cake with Fresh Blooms and Berries
-
$0.00
naked cake with flowers and berries nj

Naked 21st Birthday Cake with Fresh Blooms and Berries

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
where the wild things are smash cake nj
Where the Wild Things Are Smash Birthday Cake II
-
$0.00
where the wild things are smash cake nj

Where the Wild Things Are Smash Birthday Cake II

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
ombre blue ruffle cake nj
Cornflower Blue Up Ruffle Buttercream Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
ombre blue ruffle cake nj

Cornflower Blue Up Ruffle Buttercream Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
circus carnival cake nj
Circus 1st Birthday Cake II
-
$0.00
circus carnival cake nj

Circus 1st Birthday Cake II

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Baby Safari 1st Birthday Cake
Baby Safari 1st Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Baby Safari 1st Birthday Cake

Baby Safari 1st Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Alice in Wonderland Cake NJ
Alice In Wonderland Birthday Cake III
-
$0.00
Alice in Wonderland Cake NJ

Alice In Wonderland Birthday Cake III

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
royal prince 1st birthday cake nj
Royal Prince 1st Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
royal prince 1st birthday cake nj

Royal Prince 1st Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Barnyard 1st Birthday Cake
Barnyard 1st Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Barnyard 1st Birthday Cake

Barnyard 1st Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
little prince pillow birthday cake nj
Little Prince 1st Birthday Pillow Cake
-
$0.00
little prince pillow birthday cake nj

Little Prince 1st Birthday Pillow Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
cowgirl farm cake nj
Cowgirl Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
cowgirl farm cake nj

Cowgirl Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
vintage motorcycle 1st birthday cake nj
1st Birthday Vintage Motorcycle Cake (Buttercream)
-
$0.00
vintage motorcycle 1st birthday cake nj

1st Birthday Vintage Motorcycle Cake (Buttercream)

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
princess 1st birthday cake nj
Amira's Princess 1st Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
princess 1st birthday cake nj

Amira's Princess 1st Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
crayola crayon birthday cake NJ
Crayon Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
crayola crayon birthday cake NJ

Crayon Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Pirate Birthday Cake NJ
Pirate Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Pirate Birthday Cake NJ

Pirate Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
circus carnival cake nj
Circus Birthday Cake II
-
$0.00
circus carnival cake nj

Circus Birthday Cake II

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
winter one-derland penguin cake nj
Winter One-derland Penguin Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
winter one-derland penguin cake nj

Winter One-derland Penguin Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
ballerina 1st birthday cake nj
Ballerina Birthday 1st Birthday Cake II
-
$0.00
ballerina 1st birthday cake nj

Ballerina Birthday 1st Birthday Cake II

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
alice in wonder land custom cake nj
Alice In Wonderland Birthday Cake II
-
$0.00
alice in wonder land custom cake nj

Alice In Wonderland Birthday Cake II

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
chanel no 5 birthday cake nj
Chanel No. 5 Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
chanel no 5 birthday cake nj

Chanel No. 5 Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
construction 1st birthday cake fondant nj
Construction Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
construction 1st birthday cake fondant nj

Construction Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
amazing birthday cakes nj safari cake
Safari - Jungle 1st Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
amazing birthday cakes nj safari cake

Safari - Jungle 1st Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
disney cars birthday cake nj
Lightning McQueen Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
disney cars birthday cake nj

Lightning McQueen Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
sweet 16 pink peony cake nj
Pink Peony Sweet 16 Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
sweet 16 pink peony cake nj

Pink Peony Sweet 16 Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Alice in Wonderland Rosette Birthday Cake NJ
Alice in Wonderland Rosette Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Alice in Wonderland Rosette Birthday Cake NJ

Alice in Wonderland Rosette Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
fcb soccer birthday cake nj
FCB Soccer Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
fcb soccer birthday cake nj

FCB Soccer Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Gymnast birthday cake nj
Finley's Gymnastics Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Gymnast birthday cake nj

Finley's Gymnastics Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
where the wild things are 1st birthday cake nj
Where the Wild Things Are 1st Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
where the wild things are 1st birthday cake nj

Where the Wild Things Are 1st Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
where the wild things are smash cake nj
Where the Wild Things Are Smash Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
where the wild things are smash cake nj

Where the Wild Things Are Smash Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
turquoise buttercream ombre birthday cake nj
Tiered Buttercream Turquoise Ombre Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
turquoise buttercream ombre birthday cake nj

Tiered Buttercream Turquoise Ombre Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
pink and gold princess cake nj
Kate's Royal 50th Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
pink and gold princess cake nj

Kate's Royal 50th Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
black white gold 40th birthday cakes nj
Black, White, and Gold 40th Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
black white gold 40th birthday cakes nj

Black, White, and Gold 40th Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
cow print barn farm cake nj
Julian's Barnyard Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
cow print barn farm cake nj

Julian's Barnyard Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →