Birthday Cakes | Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Gourmet Cupcakes
Available for in-store pickup!
French Macarons
Daily Flavors & Custom Order Favors
Cakes
Buttercream & Fondant Specialty Cakes

Birthday Cakes

Browse our collection of custom specialty birthday cakes for inspiration or contact us to design something special - just for you! This collection features specialty cakes for teens and adults - birthday cakes, 40th birthday cakes, 30th birthday cakes, sweet 16 cakes, quinceanera cakes, and more. Browse our custom cake flavors here, or classic cake flavors here.   

Filter +
Italy themed 100th birthday cake
Italian Themed 100th Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Italy themed 100th birthday cake

Italian Themed 100th Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand blue sheep bake shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Black and white drip cake
Black, White, and Silver Drip Cake - NJ Birthday Cakes
-
$0.00
Black and white drip cake

Black, White, and Silver Drip Cake - NJ Birthday Cakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Our lead time is at least 7 days in advance of the pick up date however bookings are also subject to availability. If we are unable to fulfill the request you will be notified within 24 hours and your money will be refunded.

Customizations Total: $0.00

More Details →
Grey Drip Cake with Pink Macarons & Black Shards - NJ Birthday Cakes
Grey Drip Cake with Pink Macarons & Black Shards To Go Cake - NJ Birthday Cakes
-
$0.00
Grey Drip Cake with Pink Macarons & Black Shards - NJ Birthday Cakes

Grey Drip Cake with Pink Macarons & Black Shards To Go Cake - NJ Birthday Cakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Grey and Black Shard To Go Birthday Cake
Grey and Black Shard To Go Cake - NJ Birthday Cakes
-
$0.00
Grey and Black Shard To Go Birthday Cake

Grey and Black Shard To Go Cake - NJ Birthday Cakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Pink textures buttercream 30th birthday cake - NJ Birthday Cakes
Pink Buttercream Textures 30th Birthday Cake - custom cakes NJ
-
$0.00
Pink textures buttercream 30th birthday cake - NJ Birthday Cakes

Pink Buttercream Textures 30th Birthday Cake - custom cakes NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Navy and Blush Buttercream Textures Cake - by Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Navy & Blush Buttercream Textures To Go Cake Nj birthday cake
-
$0.00
Navy and Blush Buttercream Textures Cake - by Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Navy & Blush Buttercream Textures To Go Cake Nj birthday cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Tiered Buttercream Art Party Birthday Cake - by Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Edie's Art Party Painting Cake NJ birthday cake
-
$0.00
Tiered Buttercream Art Party Birthday Cake - by Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Edie's Art Party Painting Cake NJ birthday cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Naked Chocolate 80th Birthday Cake - by Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Naked Chocolate 80th Birthday cake with Fresh Pink Roses NJ custom cakes
-
$0.00
Naked Chocolate 80th Birthday Cake - by Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Naked Chocolate 80th Birthday cake with Fresh Pink Roses NJ custom cakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Logan's snowman 1st birthday cake
Logan's Snowman 1st Birthday Cake NJ best cakes
-
$0.00
Logan's snowman 1st birthday cake

Logan's Snowman 1st Birthday Cake NJ best cakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Alice In Wonderland Birthday Cake IV (Liv in One-derland!)
Alice In Wonderland Birthday Cake IV (Liv in One-derland!)
-
$0.00
Alice In Wonderland Birthday Cake IV (Liv in One-derland!)

Alice In Wonderland Birthday Cake IV (Liv in One-derland!)

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Shimmer and Shine Birthday Cake - NJ Custom Cakes
Shimmer and Shine Slumber Party Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Shimmer and Shine Birthday Cake - NJ Custom Cakes

Shimmer and Shine Slumber Party Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Fortnite Battle Royal Cake - NJ Custom Cakes, Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Fortnite Battle Royale Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Fortnite Battle Royal Cake - NJ Custom Cakes, Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Fortnite Battle Royale Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Fall Inspired Coronet Buttercream Cake NJ
Fall Inspired Coronet Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Fall Inspired Coronet Buttercream Cake NJ

Fall Inspired Coronet Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Customizations Total: $0.00

More Details →
Afro Puff Birthday Cake
Afro Puff Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Afro Puff Birthday Cake

Afro Puff Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Sculpted Shih Tzu Birthday Cake NJ
Shih Tzu Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Sculpted Shih Tzu Birthday Cake NJ

Shih Tzu Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Jewelry Inspired Birthday Cake NJ
Jewelry Inspired Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Jewelry Inspired Birthday Cake NJ

Jewelry Inspired Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Fortnite Cake - Rainbow Smash PIck Axe Birthday Cake nj
Fortnite Cake - Rainbow Smash PIck Axe Birthday Cake nj
-
$0.00
Fortnite Cake - Rainbow Smash PIck Axe Birthday Cake nj

Fortnite Cake - Rainbow Smash PIck Axe Birthday Cake nj

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
nintendo console birthday cake nj
Nintendo Console Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
nintendo console birthday cake nj

Nintendo Console Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
lego birthday cake nj
Luca's Lego BirthdayCake
-
$0.00
lego birthday cake nj

Luca's Lego BirthdayCake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
shark birthday cake nj
Shark Inspired Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
shark birthday cake nj

Shark Inspired Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
dr who birthday cake nj
Dr. Who Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
dr who birthday cake nj

Dr. Who Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Moana Inspired Buttercream Birthday Cake
Moana Inspired Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Moana Inspired Buttercream Birthday Cake

Moana Inspired Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Rainbow Unicorn Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Rainbow Unicorn Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Rainbow Unicorn Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Rainbow Unicorn Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Standing Sculpted LOL Doll Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
LOL Doll Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Standing Sculpted LOL Doll Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

LOL Doll Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Pokemon Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Pokemon Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Pokemon Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Pokemon Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Tiered Golf Themed 30th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
David's 30th Birthday Golf Themed Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Tiered Golf Themed 30th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

David's 30th Birthday Golf Themed Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Pumpkin Patch First Birthday Cake Custom Cakes NJ
Hunter's Pumpkin Patch 1st Birthday Cake NJ custom cakes
-
$0.00
Pumpkin Patch First Birthday Cake Custom Cakes NJ

Hunter's Pumpkin Patch 1st Birthday Cake NJ custom cakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Miles' Barnyard 4th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Miles' Barnyard 4th Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
Miles' Barnyard 4th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Miles' Barnyard 4th Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Buttercream 1st Birthday Cake with Fresh Flowers and Wafer Paper Butterflies - NJ custom cakes
Buttercream Floral 1st Birthday Cake with Butterflies
-
$0.00
Buttercream 1st Birthday Cake with Fresh Flowers and Wafer Paper Butterflies - NJ custom cakes

Buttercream Floral 1st Birthday Cake with Butterflies

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

This product is unavailable

More Details →
Minecraft Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Minecraft Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Minecraft Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Minecraft Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Handpainted Calvin and Hobbes Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Calvin and Hobbes Handpainted Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Handpainted Calvin and Hobbes Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Calvin and Hobbes Handpainted Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Bas Relief Inspired Buttercream Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Uriella's Bas Relief Inspired Burgundy Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Bas Relief Inspired Buttercream Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Uriella's Bas Relief Inspired Burgundy Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Kate Spade Inspired 30th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ
Kate Spade Inspired 30th Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Kate Spade Inspired 30th Birthday Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop NJ

Kate Spade Inspired 30th Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
1st Birthday Barnyard Farm Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop
Kaden's Barnyard 1st Birthday Cake NJ Birthday Cakes
-
$0.00
1st Birthday Barnyard Farm Cake - Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Kaden's Barnyard 1st Birthday Cake NJ Birthday Cakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Ariel Little Mermaid Under the Sea Theme NJ Custom Birthday Cakes
Mermaid Under the Sea Custom Birthday Cake nj
-
$0.00
Ariel Little Mermaid Under the Sea Theme NJ Custom Birthday Cakes

Mermaid Under the Sea Custom Birthday Cake nj

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Mermaid Birthday Cupcakes NJ
Mermaid Birthday Cupcakes
-
$0.00
Mermaid Birthday Cupcakes NJ

Mermaid Birthday Cupcakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Harry Potter Birthday Cupcakes NJ
Harry Potter Birthday Cupcakes
-
$0.00
Harry Potter Birthday Cupcakes NJ

Harry Potter Birthday Cupcakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Under the sea themed buttercream birthday cakes in NJ.
Under the Sea Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
Under the sea themed buttercream birthday cakes in NJ.

Under the Sea Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
unicorn cupcakes birthday cupcakes nj
Unicorn Cupcakes Birthday Cupcakes NJ
-
$0.00
unicorn cupcakes birthday cupcakes nj

Unicorn Cupcakes Birthday Cupcakes NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
charlie brown snoopy woodstock birthday cake nj custom cakes
Charlie Brown and Snoopy Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
charlie brown snoopy woodstock birthday cake nj custom cakes

Charlie Brown and Snoopy Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
number 2 #2 minnie mouse inspired birthday cake nj cakes
Number 2 Minnie Mouse Inspired Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
number 2 #2 minnie mouse inspired birthday cake nj cakes

Number 2 Minnie Mouse Inspired Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
unicorn and lol doll birthday cake nj
Unicorn and LOL Doll Inspired Birthday Cake NJ best cakes
-
$0.00
unicorn and lol doll birthday cake nj

Unicorn and LOL Doll Inspired Birthday Cake NJ best cakes

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
30th Birthday Watercolor Cake with Sugar Flowers
30th Birthday Watercolor Cake with Sugar Flowers
-
$0.00
30th Birthday Watercolor Cake with Sugar Flowers

30th Birthday Watercolor Cake with Sugar Flowers

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Flamingo To Go Birthday Cake
Flamingo To Go Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Flamingo To Go Birthday Cake

Flamingo To Go Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
Black, White, and Pink Striped To Go Birthday Cake NJ
Black, White, and Pink Striped To Go Birthday Cake NJ
-
$0.00
Black, White, and Pink Striped To Go Birthday Cake NJ

Black, White, and Pink Striped To Go Birthday Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Customizations Total: $0.00

More Details →
Watercolor Floral To Go Birthday Cake
Watercolor Floral To Go Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
Watercolor Floral To Go Birthday Cake

Watercolor Floral To Go Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
buttercream birthday cake with confetti nj cake shop
Confetti Triangle Birthday Cake
-
$0.00
buttercream birthday cake with confetti nj cake shop

Confetti Triangle Birthday Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
happy birthday to go cake nj
Happy Birthday To Go Cake
-
$0.00
happy birthday to go cake nj

Happy Birthday To Go Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
it's my birthday cake nj to go cakes
It's My Birthday To Go Cake NJ
-
$0.00
it's my birthday cake nj to go cakes

It's My Birthday To Go Cake NJ

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →
dabbing avocado birthday to go cake nj
Dabbing Avocado Birthday To Go Cake
-
$0.00
dabbing avocado birthday to go cake nj

Dabbing Avocado Birthday To Go Cake

$0.00

Brand Blue Sheep Bake Shop

More Details →